- The College Sherpa
- Posts
- America's college savings accounts just admitted college isn't worth it
America's college savings accounts just admitted college isn't worth it
How Trump's budget bill quietly transforms 529 plans into the government's first official endorsement that welding beats Harvard
If you have been religiously depositing $400 a month into your kid's 529 college fund for eight years. Today that would be roughly $40,000 of after-tax dollars sitting in an account specifically designed to encourage higher education.
Now the government is quietly telling you that you can use that same money to send my kid to welding school instead. And honestly? That might be the smartest financial advice Washington has given anyone in decades.
Buried in Trump's latest budget reconciliation bill—nicknamed the "One Big, Beautiful Bill"—is a provision that would transform 529 education savings accounts from college-only funds into career-training piggy banks. Suddenly, your Harvard fund can pay for HVAC certification, commercial driver's licenses, or cosmetology school.
The $400B policy pivot
The 529 market represents about $400 billion in family savings specifically earmarked for education. These tax-advantaged accounts have been the government's primary tool for encouraging college attendance since 1996.
But here's the kicker: The same accounts designed to funnel kids toward four-year degrees are now being retooled to fund alternative career paths. It's like McDonald's suddenly announcing that Happy Meals now come with salads as the main course.
The policy change covers a surprisingly broad range of training programs. We're talking about everything from EMT certification to cybersecurity boot camps to bar exam prep courses. If it leads to a credential that helps you get a job, it's probably covered.
This isn't some minor technical adjustment. It's the federal government officially admitting that the "college for everyone" narrative they've been pushing for three decades might not be working out so well.
The great education hedge
Think about what's actually happening here. Families have been dutifully saving for college while college costs have increased 1,200% since 1980. Meanwhile, trade jobs often pay more than many college graduate positions and come without the student debt hangover.
A certified welder can earn $60,000-$80,000 annually with minimal training costs. Compare that to the average college graduate who spends $37,000 per year for four years and graduates with $30,000 in debt to earn a median starting salary of $55,000.
The 529 expansion essentially acknowledges this math. It's the government's way of saying, "Hey, maybe we should hedge our bets on this whole college thing."
The timing couldn't be more telling. Student loan forgiveness programs are politically toxic, college enrollment is declining, and employers are increasingly dropping degree requirements for many positions. Meanwhile, skilled trades face massive worker shortages.
The certification economy
What's really fascinating is that this change officially recognizes a parallel education economy that's been thriving while traditional higher education struggles. The professional certification market is worth roughly $50 billion annually and growing at 20% per year.
Companies like Amazon and Google now offer certification programs that many employers value more than traditional degrees. A Google cybersecurity certificate costs $500 and takes six months to complete. A computer science degree costs $200,000 and takes four years.
The 529 expansion doesn't just cover initial training—it includes continuing education requirements too. So your nurse's annual CE credits, your accountant's professional development courses, and your real estate agent's license renewals all become eligible expenses.
This creates an interesting dynamic: 529 accounts could theoretically fund an entire career's worth of skill development rather than just four years of college followed by decades of student loan payments.
The political genius
From a policy perspective, this is actually brilliant politics. Republicans get to support "workforce development" and "skilled trades" while Democrats can claim they're making education more accessible and flexible.
Nobody has to admit that the college-for-everyone push was a mistake. They just quietly expand the definition of valuable education to include options that don't require taking on massive debt to study medieval literature.
The bill only needs a simple Senate majority to pass, which means it's likely to become law. When it does, expect the 529 industry to rebrand itself quickly from "college savings" to "career preparation" accounts.
The real admission
Here's what this policy change really represents: The federal government is tacitly admitting that a four-year college degree is no longer the most reliable path to middle-class prosperity.
By allowing 529 funds to pay for trade certifications and professional credentials, policymakers are essentially saying that welding certification might be a better investment than a liberal arts degree. They're just doing it quietly, without the political drama of explicitly abandoning higher education.
Your kid might still be years away from making career decisions, but you might be relieved that their college fund can now pay for whatever training actually leads to a good job. Whether that's Harvard or HVAC school, at least the tax advantages will be the same.
Sometimes the smartest policy changes are the ones that admit previous policies weren't so smart after all.