- The College Sherpa
- Posts
- This "non-profit" makes $1.2 billion off anxious parents
This "non-profit" makes $1.2 billion off anxious parents
How College Board turned standardized testing into a monopoly cash machine
Your kid gets a 1200 on their SAT and wants to retake it. That'll be $64.50, plus $93.50 if you register late because you forgot the deadline.
Want to send those scores to colleges? $12 per school. Need them rushed? Add $31 for two-day processing.
Oh, and that CSS Profile financial aid application to help pay for college? The "non-profit" that created it charges $25 for the first report, then $16 for each additional school.
Welcome to the College Board, where helping students is a billion-dollar business.
The tax-exempt goldmine
Here's what makes this beautiful: College Board is officially a charity. They pay zero taxes while generating $1.2 billion in annual revenue.
Their 14% profit margin would make most Fortune 500 companies jealous. That's $160+ million in pure profit annually — from a tax-exempt organization whose mission is supposedly "connecting students to college and opportunity."
The numbers are staggering. College Board sits on $1.1 billion in cash and investments. Their CEO pulls down over $1 million annually. Several executives earn $300K-500K in salary and benefits.
"It's the most profitable non-profit in America," says Mark Kantrowitz, a higher education analyst. "They've weaponized parental anxiety into a revenue stream."
The beautiful monopoly
College Board doesn't just dominate standardized testing — they own it completely.
SAT, PSAT, AP exams, CSS Profile financial aid applications. If you want your kid to go to college, you're paying College Board. There's literally no alternative for most of these services.
It's monopoly capitalism disguised as educational charity. And it's completely legal.
The pricing strategy is genius in its simplicity: charge for everything, multiple times.
Taking the SAT? $64.50. Want to see your scores? $12 per college. Change your mind about which schools get your scores? Another $12 each. Missed the registration deadline? Pay 45% more.
Taking AP classes? $94 per exam. Many students take 3-5 AP tests, so families shell out $300-500 per year just for the privilege of taking tests.
The anxiety economy
College Board has mastered the psychology of desperate parents.
They know families will pay anything to give their kids an edge. The stakes feel existential — one bad test score could derail college dreams.
So they've built an entire economy around that fear.
Want better scores? College Board sells prep materials. Need more testing opportunities? They offer additional test dates. Worried about fairness? They created an "Adversity Index" (while charging for the privilege of using it).
"Parents are trapped," explains education consultant Sarah Chen. "College Board controls the gates to higher education. They can charge whatever they want because families have no choice."
The non-profit loophole
Here's the kicker: College Board maintains its tax-exempt status while operating like a for-profit corporation.
They argue they're serving the public good by standardizing college admissions. Never mind that they're making hundreds of millions doing it.
The tax advantages are massive. No corporate income tax on $1.2 billion in revenue. No property taxes on their Manhattan headquarters. Donors can write off gifts to the organization.
Meanwhile, actual for-profit education companies pay full taxes while providing similar services.
"It's regulatory arbitrage," says tax policy expert Jennifer Martinez. "They get all the benefits of non-profit status while running a highly profitable business."
The future of extortion
College Board's grip on admissions is starting to weaken. The UC system eliminated SAT requirements. Many schools made tests optional during COVID and kept those policies.
But don't worry about College Board's executives. They're already pivoting.
AP exams are growing internationally. They're expanding into digital testing. The CSS Profile now covers more schools than ever.
Plus, they've got that $1.1 billion war chest to weather any storms.
The ultimate irony
The most twisted part? College Board charges families to apply for financial aid.
Think about that logic. The people who need help paying for college have to pay money just to ask for help.
It's like charging homeless people for soup kitchen applications.
A family earning $40,000 per year — who desperately needs aid — pays the same $25 CSS Profile fee as a family earning $400,000.
"It's the definition of regressive taxation," notes Kantrowitz. "The organization supposed to help students access college is charging the students who can least afford it."
The charity that forgot its mission
College Board started in 1900 with a noble goal: creating standardized admissions tests to help talented students from any background access elite colleges.
125 years later, they've become the thing they were supposed to disrupt — a barrier between students and education.
They've turned what should be a public service into a private money machine, all while maintaining the legal fiction that they're a charity.
As one former College Board employee told me: "We stopped asking 'How can we help students?' and started asking 'How much can we charge?'"
The answer, apparently, is $1.2 billion per year.